Despite not having saks new york read the entire series of Pittacus Lore (a pseudonym for a group of writers behind saks new york "I Am Number Four"), I consider myself a fan of the books "The Lorien Legacies." To tell the truth, saks new york just read the first two books, but the mythology and twists have delighted me, and their characters. We can compare the series to the Hunger Games, which exerts an undeniable influence on the tale of the survivors of Lorien: narrative, fast and focused on action, saks new york it is most similar, as well as the atmosphere of tension concerning an impending war. This is one of the many things I like in this series.
Unfortunately, saks new york I can not say the same about the first book, "I Am Number saks new york Four". This is one of the weakest, cliches and repetitive books I have ever read. Finish reading with that feeling of "I've read / seen it somewhere before." So you can imagine my surprise to find out how the series is epic and excellent in "The Power Of Six" after a first book so weak. Only I will not say that the book is a total waste because the action scenes are quite hefty and interesting. But apart from that, there is almost nothing to applaud in "I Am Number Four" - unlike the rest of "The Power of Six," which left me stuck in the story day and night.
"I Am Number Four" carries all the clichés that we can expect from a typical story of American action, saks new york and also gives us the added bonus of also carry all the typical clichés of modern YA novel. saks new york This time, there is a female narrator, not a supernatural partner, not a great mystery regarding this partner to be solved. The main character himself, John, is the supernatural partner with a dark secret and a lifetime of pain. Could be an interesting saks new york twist on the formula of YA, but unfortunately it was badly used: we still have a good guy and a good guy as diabetes and sweets that give young lady, and we still have that old cliché "I'm against everything and everyone who I love" , "love transforms", "love saves" ... honestly, there is a shopping saks new york finger on it all.
As for the action movie cliches, which I mentioned before, they are also there: there is the master (Henri) responsible for training; the girl in danger (Sarah) that is for nothing than to scream and ... well, be in danger; the nerdy and clumsy friend (Sam), who now and then plays a trick to break the tension; the pet is not a pet (Bernie Kosar); and of course, the girl who experienced manja wars (Six). But I'm just talking about the characters. Not got the story, which seems to catch all the silliest and mindless formulas teen movies and action movies of the 80s and spread blindly through the pages. I'm surprised that the book did not end with a dance and a competition for king and queen, or a Soviet invasion (though the book ended rather have a party and a small alien invasion, ops.)
There is a clear inspiration saks new york from other YA that were released around the same time, maybe just to get on the bandwagon and sell more, maybe just because there was not enough idea, I do not know. What I know is that the relationship of Sarah and John, at least in this first book, it's so cliché that can be compared to Bella and Edward. Sorry fans, but I can not see otherwise. There are numerous parallels between "I Am Number Four" and "Twilight", from the characterization of the characters to the direction the story takes. And while "Twilight" not be so bad as everyone saks new york says (at least in my opinion), it is undeniable that the formula of Stephenie Meyer's hit, cliché and boring. "I Am Number Four" used this formula, that turned out badly. So what is considered a "mildly saks new york successful" sales, and received saks new york harsh criticism. Of course, with the following books, the series was becoming increasingly acclaimed and began to make a mark of originality and quality, but "I Am Number Four" was not so. So much so that, if you've read "The Power of Six", you know that many things that happened in "I Am Number Four" are hastily resolved (eg, the novel by John with Sarah) so that it can be focus on other things.
I think even the authors saks new york repented of what they did in "I Am Number saks new york Four" to make a decision like this. As I said, there seems to be a very commercial inspiration in the making of "I Am Number Four", with so many clichés, never trying to be much more than it already is, without trying to do something creative ... Thank God that changed in " The Power of Six. " It seems that we abandon the "Afternoon Session" to do something really epic, really creative and really intelligent. YA fled the conventional formula used in "I Am Number Four" to invest in development of characters, saks new york plot twists, things like that. It's like "I Am Number Four" was just a bad past for a sé
No comments:
Post a Comment